the fresh films reviews

S I N C E   1 9 9 7










 

Mean Girls (2004)

Directed by:
Mark Waters

COUNTRY
USA

GENRE
Comedy/Drama
NORWEGIAN TITLE
Mean Girls
RUNNING TIME
97 minutes

Produced by:
Tony Shimkin
Lorne Michaels

Written by (based on the novel by Rosalind Wiseman):
Tina Fey


Cast includes:

CHARACTER ACTOR/ACTRESS RATING
Cady Heron Lindsay Lohan ½
Regina George Rachel McAdams ½
Ms. Norbury Tina Fey
Mr. Duvall Tim Meadows ½
Mrs. George Amy Poehler ½
Cady's Mom Ana Gasteyer
Gretchen Wieners Lacey Chabert ½
Janis Ian Lizzy Caplan ½
Damian Daniel Franzese
Cady's Dad Neil Flynn
Aaron Samuels Jonathan Bennett
Karen Smith Amanda Seyfried

 

Review

The influence from Heathers is almost painfully obvious throughout this familiar, well-meaning, and over-Americanised high-school film. The only thing missing in the link to Michael Lehmann's 1989 film is the Christian Slater character. The three Heathers and Winona Ryder's Veronica Sawyer are represented with almost a hundred per cent likeness.

Writers Tina Fey (script) and Rosalind Wiseman (novel) have also clearly drawn inspiration from The Breakfast Club, but the characterisations in Mean Girls are much less subtle and more stereotypical. The latter is a surprising flaw for a film that seems to be taking its target group rather seriously, because if it is one thing Mean Girls succeeds with, it is having a basic understanding of the teenage (girl) way of thinking and of the shortcomings of the educational system, which is brilliantly represented through the pinpointed Mr. Duvall character.

Unfortunately, there is too much silliness bulging between the poignant observations and the occasional hysterical comedy. In the end, very few of these girls feel like actual human beings. They should have been caricatured versions of existing types, not altogether constructed puppets. Or perhaps I'm just too used to the European school system to be able to appreciate this.

Copyright © 05.09.2008 Fredrik Gunerius Fevang

[BACK TO INDEX]

[HAVE YOUR SAY]