the fresh films reviews

S I N C E   1 9 9 7










 

The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (2007)

Directed by:
Andrew Dominik

COUNTRY
USA

GENRE
Western
NORWEGIAN TITLE
Mordet på Jesse James av den feige Robert Ford
RUNNING TIME
160 minutes

Produced by:
Jules Daly
Dede Gardner
Brad Pitt
Ridley Scott
David Valdes

Written by:
Andrew Dominik


Cast includes:

CHARACTER ACTOR/ACTRESS RATING
Jesse James Brad Pitt ½
Robert Ford Casey Affleck ½
Charley Ford Sam Rockwell
Frank James Sam Shephard
Zee James Mary-Louise Parker
Dick Liddil Paul Schneider ½
Wood Hite Jeremy Renner
Ed Miller Garret Dillahunt
Dorothy Evans Zooey Deschanel
Capt. Henry Craig Michael Parks
James H. Timberlake Ted Levine
Wilbur Ford Pat Healy

 

Review

The undoubtedly interesting relationship between Jesse James and Bob Ford, with the fascinating ambiguity and naivety that, by all accounts, defined the latter, is the main course in this overlong, somewhat conceited film by Andrew Dominik. The story should have been told in half the time, and preferably without the following three aspects: 1) the documentary-emulating voice-over, 2) the suspense-deflating narrative structure, and 3) Brad Pitt as Jesse James. In order to convey the complexity of the James/Ford gang’s final days, Dominik seems determined to include every parenthesis and sub-clause. And he ostensibly justifies it with his deglamorised portrait of the West. Unfortunately, he seems to confuse a deglamorisation of the Jesse James saga with a deconstruction. It might well be truthful, but it's also ploddingly pragmatic. As a result, we’re not given any juice in exchange for the fun we’re deprived of. Not even a tint of Jesse James’ wild side – or any other side of him, for that matter. In Dominik’s version, James is reduced to a Brad Pitt puppet in cowboy boots, leaving Casey Affleck’s magnificent portrait of Robert Ford the film’s most (almost only) interesting aspect.

Copyright © 31.12.2007 Fredrik Gunerius Fevang

[BACK TO INDEX]

[HAVE YOUR SAY]