the fresh films reviews

S I N C E   1 9 9 7









 

Comes a Horseman (1978)

Directed by:
Alan J. Pakula

COUNTRY
USA

GENRE
Western/Drama

NORWEGIAN TITLE
Det kom en cowboy

RUNNING TIME
118 minutes

Produced by:
Gene Kirkwood
Dan Paulson
Written by:
Dennis Lynton Clark


Cast includes:

CHARACTER ACTOR/ACTRESS RATING
Frank "Buck" Athearn James Caan
Ella Connors Jane Fonda ½
Jacob "J.W." Ewing Jason Robards
Neil Atkinson George Grizzard ½
Dodger Richard Farnsworth ½
Julie Blocker Jim Davis -
Billy Joe Meyent Mark Harmon -
Virgil Hoverton Macon McCalman

 

Review

For about three quarters of its running time, Comes a Horseman is an earnest, beautiful account of mid-20th-century ranching, hardships, and companionship – a fine little homage to nature, farming, and the Western storytelling tradition. This was Alan J. Pakula's follow-up to his magnum opus, 1976's All the President's Men, and despite it being his most expensive film up until this point, it was in many ways also his least artistically ambitious. The build-up is patient, the pace slow, and the picture balances constantly on a hair's breadth between poignant and sluggish. Still, when all the dramatic elements work in tandem and Pakula gives his performers room to shine, Comes a Horseman is as good a western as any from this period. Only during the finale, when cluttered plotting and Pakula's clumsy action direction take over, does it all (almost) come tumbling down. Richard Farnsworth, who had mostly appeared as an extra and stuntman prior to this film, delivers a wonderful, Academy Award-nominated performance as Jane Fonda's cowhand Dodger.

Copyright © 12.08.2025 Fredrik Gunerius Fevang

[BACK TO INDEX]

[HAVE YOUR SAY]